News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 Bolt of fear: climate-change sceptic blasts 'scare' campaign 

Bolt of fear: climate-change sceptic blasts 'scare' campaign

2/09/2008 2:57:00 PM
MORNINGTON Peninsula Shire has challenged controversial newspaper columnist Andrew Bolt's claims that the shire is irresponsibly scaring residents about the threat of rising temperatures due to global warming.

Mr Bolt, a self-confessed climate-change sceptic, wrote in the Herald Sun last Friday that the shire had pulled a "sick stunt" and terrified its residents.

"Mornington Peninsula Shire has [sent] each ratepayer a glossy magazine warning that warming may well kill them," he wrote. "I was so cross I wasn't sure if I was still trembling from fever or fury."

Mr Bolt was referring to the shire's colour booklet Climate change: What we are doing about it, which was sent to all residents prior to the shire's 12 climate change meetings.

Ten meetings have been held so far, attracting a combined audience of more than 2000 residents.

The last two meetings are at the New Peninsula Baptist Church, Craigie Road, Mt Martha, at 6pm on Wednesday, and at Hastings Hall in High Street at 6pm on Thursday.

Mr Bolt wrote on his opinion page that "global warming prophets have had great success in screaming at us to repent or die".

"No scare is now deemed too extreme to make us cut our satanic gases.

"This love of the Big Scare has worked its way down the global-warming food chain. Prime Minister Kevin Rudd even warned Parliament that warming could unleash malaria and dengue fever on us and cause another 1400 Australians a year to die from heatstroke.

"You don't often come across scaremongering so brazen - or so irresponsibly exaggerated."

On Monday, mayor Bev Colomb challenged Mr Bolt's account:

"The council's climate-change booklet provides the local community with the results of research by the CSIRO into the potential impacts of climate change on the Mornington Peninsula.

"Its findings are consistent with the overwhelming weight of scientific opinion, nationally and internationally.

"The information we have provided to our community is, unquestionably, cause for concern but not alarm, and that is the response that we are getting from our residents."

Cr Colomb said the booklet and climate change meetings did more than provide information:

"They provide advice on what the community can do to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, to reduce energy and ... water use, and to improve our recycling performance.

"The overwhelming response of the community has been positive.

"People want to be informed, and they want the opportunity to engage with the council over climate change, and we are providing that opportunity."

Greg Hunt of the Western Port Greenhouse Alliance, of which the shire is a member, said the climate-change meetings were inspired by a CSIRO report prepared for the alliance and released in June.

It warned of rising sea levels in Western Port that would affect low-lying parts of Hastings, Tyabb, Somerville, Crib Point, Stony Point, Somers and Shoreham.

The report also warned of increased storm surges, bushfires and high temperatures unless measures were taken to combat climate change. Mr Hunt said it was commonsense not to waste energy.

"Why not cut our unnecessary use and save ourselves money along the way?"

He said the dangers of hotter weather were real.

"Perhaps the blinkered Mr Bolt can tell us about the 37,000 heat-related deaths in Europe in 2003 and why we shouldn't prepare for this possibility."

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Page:
1

Comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
I pity any council that relies on CSIRO climate reports because its track record is abysmal. See http://mclean.ch/climate/EE%2017-1_03%20McLean%20ok.pdf and http://mclean.ch/climate/CCA_review.pdf. And can any scientific consensus be demonstrated? I very much doubt it. See http://mclean.ch/climate/What_consensus_col.pdf This is no credible evidence whatsoever that carbon dioxide emissions have caused warming. None. The IPCC's so called evidence was just correlations and the CSIRO's ... well it doesn't present any. Evidence of rising sea level is very weak too. The Maldives certainly haven't disappeared and the claims about its demise have been around for at least 10 years. Perhaps the blinkered Greg Hunt can tell us why he attributes the European deaths during the 2003 heat wave, caused by a low pressure cell directing warm African air into Europe, should be attributed to global warming rather than people being on holidays and not being present to care for their elderly parents. Bev Colomb and Greg Hunt need to look at the facts and stop listening to the hysterical outbursts of people with vested interests but little or no evidence.
Posted by John on 3/09/2008 6:31:42 PM
Recent research in Adelaide showed quite clearly there is no significant risk of death from heatwaves. See http://www.mja.com.au/public/issues/187_11_031207/nit10385_f m.html There is no evidence to support more storm surges either. This is blatant scaremongering. Mr Hunt needs to get some competent scientific advisers.
Posted by MAGB on 3/09/2008 7:29:22 PM
I don't particularly care for your enmity with Andrew Bolt - that's a matter for you and he to decide, but pulling numbers which are completely out of context out of thin air is completely indecent. First of all, 37,000 people aren't confirmed dead. It's estimated that 37,000 died due to complications from the heat wave of 2003. It's splitting hairs but it's an important point because estimates are going to be used to refute your argument. Now here's something you do not know. More people die in Europe each winter than they do in a heatwave of 2003 proportions. I'm not kidding. And I have source: http://www.bbc.co.uk/shropshire/features/2002/11/be_warm.sht ml In that source there is an estimate that 25,000 people die in winter each year from the cold, or from cold related diseases in the UK. Just in the UK. 25,000 in one normal winter in one European country, or 37,000 in one extra-ordinary heatwave across more than 20 countries? Imagine what a cold snap can do. In fact, even in New South Wales, hospitalization numbers are 6-8% higher in the winter than in the summer. The fact of the matter is that your numbers are extraordinarily high but they're not comparable to anything because you don't provide relevance to them. 37000 is a big number, and that's about it. It is acknowledged fact that humans have survived and flourished in Europe during the medieval warming period with higher temperatures than today - the Vikings even farmed in Greenland, and subsequently abandoned the effort when the Earth cooled again. If you want to argue science with Andrew Bolt, you'd best get your statistics right.
Posted by Leo on 3/09/2008 11:05:20 PM
If Mornington Peninsula Mayor Bev Colomb believes that Andrew Bolt is incorrect, she is to be pitied. Many scientists dispute the claims of the climate change alarmists. At a rail freight conference held at the St Kilda Town Hall recently, I listened in amazement as a claimed environmentalist suggested that sea levels would 'rise eight metres.' These sorts of claims are ludicrous. Kevin Rudd and his Labor cohorts want to force an unnecessary greenhouse gas reduction tax onto Australian businesses. Make no mistake, this will cost Australians their jobs - for no reason at all. China and India are looking after their citizens, and want to remove individuals from the poverty trap. Naturally (because they are both sensible) they will not have a bar of greenhouse gas reductions. Who will be worst affected by Kevin Rudd's madcap scheme? It will be the middle class, because the poorest Australians will receive compensation increased transfer (welfare) payments. and the wealthiest five or 10 per cent will know how to profit from any governmental changes. Unfortunately some local Liberals such as Greg Hunt are refusing to see the idiocy of this. At this time in Australia's history, we need real leadership - not politicians and mayors who force the 'Green Religion' down our throats and make some of us lose our jobs! Andrew Bolt, keep on speaking the truth.
Posted by Sceptic on 4/09/2008 9:46:17 PM

Post A Comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.

16/12/2008 | So we now have desperate parents attempting to bribe teachers to get their children into a selective high school. What a sad indictment of our education policies, the holy grail of which is parental choice.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...